How far do the sources X and Y challenge source W about the telling supplying of the army?
The sources discuss the effective supplying of an army. offset W shows that the supplying was unspoilt to the army and that in that location didnt seem to be any problems. However sources X and Y are opposite and suggest that the supplying of the army was poor people and had a dramatic impact of the soldiers. They are all main(a) sources and source X and Y are more reliable based on the people who have written them. reference X is a letter in Crimea therefore there is nothing to hide and defend the government for their mis come acrosss. However it is by a Doctor who might not of experienced everything that new(prenominal) soldiers could of. Source Y is by an officer who experienced what happened in Crimea so the source is more reliable based on the provenance.
Source W indicates the effectiveness of the supplies delivered to the army greatest chew up for his exertions in supplying our men with nourishment. This demonstrates that they army were well supplied by Britain the best they possibly could with the conditions in Crimea.
The source also implies that the food is supplied regularly and efficiently for the army no army was ply with more punctuality, undoubtedly suggesting that the supplying of food was always good and that the soldiers were always fed. The blame for the soldiers dying was their birth according to source W for any one day, except it had been through his own neglect. Therefore the army dying and not fighting up to certain standards is because they did not feed themselves properly or take care of their needs efficiently. Source W is a patriarchal source by William Russell who from my own knowledge spent just about of the appalling winter in a hotel away from the take care line and may not of witnessed the real impact that is describe in source W. Also it is for the newspaper and therefore may have changed some aspects of the truth to keep morale dismissal in Britain. Overall source W is...If you want to condense a full essay, order it on our website: Ordercustompaper.com
If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my paper
No comments:
Post a Comment